## Advocates of active management admit that only a minority of mutual funds will outperform their benchmarks, but they argue there is still a significant probability of success. According to the data Rick Ferri provides in his new book, The Power of Passive Investing (Wiley, 2010), the odds of an actively managed fund beating an index […]

Advocates of active management admit that only a minority of mutual funds will outperform their benchmarks, but they argue there is still a significant probability of success. According to the data Rick Ferri provides in his new book, The Power of Passive Investing (Wiley, 2010), the odds of an actively managed fund beating an index fund are as high as 42% in any given year, and about 30% over five years. Surely by zeroing in on funds with good track records and low costs you can give yourself a decent chance of building an index-beating portfolio. Right?

Ferri takes this argument apart with simple math. The key point here is that almost no one builds a portfolio with a single mutual fund. It’s far more common to select several funds in various asset classes. But here’s the rub: to determine the odds that the entire portfolio will beat its benchmark, you need to combine the probabilities that each individual fund will outperform.

Here’s a simplified example. Since the probability of flipping heads is one in two, you’ll flip two heads in a row one time in four (2 × 2), and three in a row just one time in eight (2 × 2 × 2). The same principle is at work when you select mutual funds in a diversified portfolio. What are the chances you will pick multiple winners?

### Not zero — but close

To test this idea, Ferri took the performance data of actual mutual funds and programmed a computer to create thousands of portfolios using three, five, and 10 active funds. Then he compared these with portfolios of index funds in the same asset classes.

He found that over five-year periods, the probability of a five-fund portfolio beating comparable index funds was 16%. Even then, only 5% of these outperformed the index-fund portfolio by more than 0.5%. By contrast, 63% of the portfolios underperformed by more than 0.5%.

When he went out 10 years, the odds were reduced even further. A trivial 0.8% of the portfolios outperformed the index funds by more than 0.5%, while 70% underperformed by at least that much.

Of course, most people have a horizon much longer than 10 years. And as Ferri’s model demonstrates, over a typical investor’s lifetime, the probability that an actively managed mutual fund portfolio will outperform index funds is vanishingly small.

So it’s simply not true to say that actively managed funds have no chance of earning higher returns than index funds over the long term. The probability is not zero — it’s just statistically indistinguishable from zero.

Coming up next: I’ll be posting excerpts from an interview I did with Rick Ferri about his book. At the end of the series, I’ll give readers an opportunity to win a copy of The Power of Passive Investing.

1. @ Dan: Thx. This does provide more understanding about active vs passive.

While I do understand the point being is trying to build a portfolio on a group of mutual funds alone is probably going to net low to negative returns vs indexing. I found out the hard way with my first venture into investing years ago…tuition one commenter put it. Out of curiosity does this mean, in theory, that for those who have built a good couch potatoe portfolio of index and or ETFs that it MAY be worth adding one or two select well perfoming/ high quality mutual funds at some point if desired? Not in terms of myself but just as part of a larger discussion or picture because based on talking to others MFs are still popular for DIYers especially those who rely heavily on thier local banks for advice (no offense to bankers).

2. @Marie: Every time you add an actively managed fund to a portfolio (even if most of the other funds are passive) you lower your probability of matching an all-index-fund portfolio. Of course, there is always the possibility that the one or two active funds will allow you to beat the market. It's just a very small possibility, and it comes at the risk of even greater underperformance.

• Interesting. I think the confusion over active vs passive funds is finally clearing. Thx.

3. All of our hearts go out to people from Japan inside this time of pain.

• Absolutely. A good reminder that 1) Mother Nature will always win, and 2) there are more important things to value in world over money. KInd of makes your annoyance over credit card fees and how much your house is worth seem a little less important. Good.

5. Nice commentary. last thirty days I uncovered this internet internet site and desired to permit you be conscious that i’ve been gratified, heading via your site’s posts. I should certainly be signing equally as much as the RSS feed and can wait around for another post. Cheers, Glen

6. Well this could likely be considered a very good article, instead beneficial an I be conscious that it is in real truth instead crucial particularly for people teenagers who’ve dermis problems.

7. Useful article, approval for demography the the perfect time to specify it together. I like the administering you could be demography your blog. I’ll be bookmarking your internet internet site therefore i can accrue up from the future. wants to discover added posts soon.

8. Hi from Paris! Can I quote a post within your blog with the link to you? I’ve tried contacting you regarding this problem but it seems i cant reach you, please reply when get a moment, thanks.

9. If the equine feels restless or starts acting crazy, this could previously be an indication of colic. The man or lady will require to remain a small way more the perfect time to create an assessment as a consequence of the simple fact it is in real truth also doable how the four-legged friend was spooked by something.

10. Can I simply say what a relief to search out somebody who actually knows what theyre speaking about on the internet. You positively know the best way to bring a problem to gentle and make it important. More individuals must learn this and perceive this aspect of the story. I cant believe youre no more common because you definitely have the gift.

11. I precisely needed to say thanks once more. I am not sure the things I could possibly have achieved in the absence of these thoughts documented by you directly on my situation. It truly was a frustrating setting in my circumstances, but encountering this expert style you managed the issue forced me to weep with delight. I am just happier for this information and then trust you find out what a great job you are accomplishing training many people through your web blog. More than likely you have never met all of us.

12. I cling on to listening in the direction of rumor speak about obtaining boundless internet dependent grant programs so i’ve been looking for near to for the best internet site to obtain one. Could you reveal to me please, especially where could i arrive around some?

13. I do like the manner in which you have presented this particular concern plus it really does provide us some fodder for thought. Nonetheless, from everything that I have witnessed, I just simply wish as the responses pile on that people remain on point and not start upon a tirade regarding the news of the day. Anyway, thank you for this exceptional piece and while I do not necessarily go along with it in totality, I respect the perspective.

14. Man I like this comment and it was so fabulous and I am definetly going to bookmark it. I Have to say the Superb analysis this article has is trully remarkable.Who goes that extra mile these days? Well Done Just another tip you shouldget a Translator Application for your Worldwide Audience .

15. An extra 1 pricks the debris , or at minimal another web log post bites the dust. Your weblog rocks my article meshing hold up the terrific causes .

16. Wow, incredible blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your website is magnificent, as well as the content!

17. I’d perpetually want to be update on new content on this internet site , bookmarked ! .

18. Hot email will help me I am thinking about a business that will be marketing to B2B everything I see helps me understand the good and bad this is the kind of information i need, thanks

19. I cling on to listening in the direction of rumor speak about obtaining boundless internet dependent grant programs so i’ve been looking for near to for the best internet site to obtain one. Could you reveal to me please, especially where could i arrive around some?

20. You will find undoubtedly a great deal of facts this way to consider. It really is a wonderful denote start up. When i give feelings earlier mentioned as common inspiration nonetheless clearly there are questions including the one anyone raise up the location where the biggest element is going to be working in genuine great belief. We dress in?capital t determine if guidelines get come forth close to such things as that will, nonetheless Most likely that a job is usually obviously defined as a good video game. Equally girls and boys feel the effect involving just a moment’s enjoyment, throughout their particular existence.

21. Whats up ! Love your ; thanks for sharing it with everyone

22. Nice article. last thirty days I uncovered this internet internet site and desired to permit you be conscious that i’ve been gratified, heading via your site’s posts. I should certainly be signing equally as much as the RSS feed and should certainly wait around for another post. best Regards, Mateus