Unwrap portfolio with index mutual funds

The McEvers want to reduce their portfolio fees in order to save more for retirement.

  2 Premium content image


From the June 2014 issue of the magazine.

  2 Premium content image
Photograph by Jenna Marie Wakani

Photograph by Jenna Marie Wakani

 The problem

With a paid-for home and six-figure portfolio, the couple’s friends think they have little to worry about. But “I do worry,” says Denise, who at 53 makes a good income as a dental hygienist. However, she enjoys no major benefits or employer-sponsored pension plan. Neither does Mark, 55, who lost his job in April 2011 and has worked only in contract positions since. They were investing $1,200 a month in RRSPs but ceased adding to Mark’s portion in November. The bank “wrap” program they’re invested in charges 2.5%. They’d prefer the lower fees of a “Couch Potato” but “don’t know how to do it ourselves.”

Portfolio Makeover June

Tony de ThomasisFinancial planner Tony de Thomasis, of De Thomas Financial Corp., says the couple are moderate-risk investors and should be comfortable with an asset allocation of 75% equities to 25% bonds and cash. As retirement approaches and if markets cooperate, portfolios would be gradually rebalanced to raise the fixed-income weight by 8% every five years or so.

Rather than recommend an all-ETF portfolio, de Thomasis prefers index mutual funds that tilt portfolios toward small-cap and value stocks, such as those available from Dimensional Fund Advisors (DFA) or Invesco PowerShares. Also in the mix are BMO ETFs that provide more traditional large-cap equity exposure to the major North American stock indexes as well as some currency hedging to smooth out fluctuations between the U.S. dollar and Canadian dollar. He uses one actively managed mutual fund, Cundill Recovery, for much of the global stock exposure. For fixed income, he leans to shorter-term bond funds and floating-rate securities in order to lower the risk of spikes in interest rates and thus declining long-term bond prices.

De Thomasis believes the couple can cut their total investment management and financial planning costs to an all-in fee of 1.5%, while being subjected to less stress.

Since markets tend to move in three- to six-year cycles, de Thomasis would strive to rebalance the major asset classes whenever one strays 20% away from the target range, whether up or down.

Do you want a portfolio makeover from MoneySense? If so, send an email describing your situation to letters@moneysense.ca

2 comments on “Unwrap portfolio with index mutual funds

  1. Paying 2.50% annual management or investment fees is a ripoff. Even paying 1.50% still seems high and if they want index funds then 0.50% to 0.75% annual costs seems more in line and fair.

    Yes, lower annual management or investment fees will make a big difference but is only one part of the 3 steps to a strong financial foundation and solution.

    The main problem they have is that like most Canadians, first they don’t save enough. I’m sorry but putting $1,200 a month in RRSP’s is not going to be enough for a decent retirement.

    Second, they need to maximize their RRSP’s, TFSA’s and non-registered accounts to really have a great nest egg that will see them through decades of retirement and leaving a legacy if that is their goal too.

    Even at a modest 4.00% rate of return compounded over the next 12 years, $30,000 per year would add up to $450,770 at 65 years old. They started late unless they have a lot more financial assets and investments that this article is not pointing out.


  2. Put it all in the Mawer Balanced Fund. Low MER and top notch returns for its category. Seriously it is that easy. I have been in this fund 21 years.


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *