CRA TFSA ‘crackdown’ no cause for alarm

Contribute to and invest your TFSA as usual



Online only.

(Getty Images)

(Getty Images)

Tax Free Savings Accounts (TFSAs) have come in for a drubbing lately, based on various media reports of a Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) “crackdown” on frequent traders who have racked up excessive gains.

On social media there seem to be a lot of ordinary investors taken aback by this, even though as I have said on Twitter, 99.99% of the almost 10 million Canadians who have a TFSA hardly need to worry about this obscure attack on a few sophisticated frequent traders of speculative stocks in their accounts.

Anyone who holds index funds, ETFs, blue-chip stocks or fixed income and is holding for the long-term should stick with their plans for using their TFSA, including making a full maximum contribution early in January. Frequent online traders making dozens of trades a day are the target, especially if their trading patterns causes the CRA to view them as running businesses inside their TFSAs: if you or I traded that often we’d be losing a lot in trading commissions, even at the $5 or $10 a pop that most online brokerages charge.

As I have also pointed out, TFSAs are the mirror image of the RRSP, which has been around more than half a century. Even if there is a way to define what an “excessive” gain is, does this mean Ottawa would go back through half a century’s worth of deferred RRSP gains? It seems hardly likely.

This is really a tempest in a teapot and I’d hate to think anyone scared off by this would fail to top up their TFSA early in January. As I’ve also said more than once, the TFSA is just about the best game in an otherwise highly taxed town. And as I said in this blog a few weeks ago, the uncovering of an end run that lets the wealthy contort their finances so as to collect for three years the Guaranteed Income Supplement (intended for the elderly poor) suggests that either GIS or TFSA rules or both may get tinkered with sometime in the next few years. So it’s best to fill up TFSAs while you can, just in case Ottawa starts to curtail their use for whatever reason. And that includes maximizing your children’s TFSAs if you’re able.

The CRA has rolled out an 8-point list for a TFSA “audit” but a quick scan of the items should reassure ordinary investors that there’s little cause for alarm. I can see how some knowledgeable do-it-yourself investors who love to research stocks and spend time at their trading terminals might feel a bit uncomfortable but it’s pretty clear the CRA is more worried about those who make many (10 or 15 a day) trades and who quickly liquidate their positions. Also on the list are speculative non-dividend paying stocks and people, those who use margin or debt to leverage their positions, and those who advertise their willingness to purchase certain securities: again, well outside the realm of the ordinary investor trying to create a little tax-free dividend or interest income.

The irony about all this attention to a handful of professional speculators gaming the system for spectacular capital gains is that far too many TFSA users are doing the precise opposite. If all you do is go with a default GIC or low interest-bearing investment in your TFSA, then you’re not doing this vehicle justice. Chris Cottier, a Vancouver-based investment adviser with Richardson GMP, says any young investor with large debts–especially high-interest credit-card debt–should forget about TFSAs until they’ve eliminated that debt. Very few investments can create gains greater than those accruing to those who pay off credit-card debt that approaches 20% per year.

But when you are debt-free (except the mortgage), you’ll be better off holding equities in your TFSA than fixed-income investments sporting today’s minuscule interest rates.

MoneySense has long espoused a passive “Couch Potato” approach to investing in broadly diversified portfolios spread over geographies and multiple asset classes. That approach is particularly apt for TFSAs and is clearly the polar opposite of the type of investor the CRA is looking for.

So when January rolls around, do not hesitate to max out your TFSA contribution for the year 2015 and if it’s a quality ETF from a well-established manufacturer, I wouldn’t waste a minute’s thought on the CRA.

Jonathan Chevreau is Chief Findependence Officer for


6 comments on “CRA TFSA ‘crackdown’ no cause for alarm

  1. How can the CRA clam speculative stocks will get you audited, if they allow them in the TFSA?


    • They make up the rules as they go, it is the government, it is what they do.


  2. Taxpayers who are re-assessed based on mishandled contributions or other TFSA issues may request an “administrative review” from the CRA TFSA unit.


  3. It’s pretty unlikely you’d be audited by the CRA, unless you’re running a trading business using your TFSA. See here for more information:

    I think people are paying attention to this matter more than they need to be. Like Jonathan says, for 99.9%, it’s a non issue. No need fear-mongering.


  4. John as you know, what the CRA lists as guidance, isn’t neccessary what they do in real life. As you know through various media reports, the CRA are activiely auditing people, who have a rate of return higher then GIC’s and Bonds. If you ask any CRA auditor and refrain from giving out their names, they will comfirm it. From what I understand, it’s being pushed from senior supervisors, because of recent US stock market gains. If you arer an ordinary investor, yes you will have a higher rate of return then bonds, just because you invested in the US stock market.


    • CRA = Mafia


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *