TFSAs for young savers

Just launching your career? TFSAs offer flexibility for both short- and long-term goals

  2 Premium content image


From the September/October 2015 issue of the magazine.

  2 Premium content image
BLAIR STIVER King City, ON At just 23, and with no mortgage and no dependents, Blair is able to sock away about half his paycheque. He’s set up a TFSA at a discount brokerage and makes automatic contributions to a portfolio of low-cost mutual funds.(Photograph by Jaime Hogge)

At just 23, and with no mortgage and no dependents, Blair is able to sock away about half his paycheque. He’s set up a TFSA at a discount brokerage and makes automatic contributions to a portfolio of low-cost mutual funds. (Photograph by Jaime Hogge)

Blair Stiver knows something about crunching numbers. The 23-year-old from King City, Ont., is a newly minted graduate in accounting and is now working as a bookkeeper for a nearby printing company. He’s even built a spreadsheet plotting out a three-year plan for his TFSA. “I want to get as much in there as I can now to give it more time to grow.” For young people just starting their careers, the TFSA offers something their parents never enjoyed: the possibility of building a retirement nest-egg that will grow entirely tax-free. Not only might they be able to avoid investing in taxable accounts, they might never even need an RRSP.

Quiz: Test your TFSA smarts »


There are several reasons why the TFSA has great appeal for young investors. The first is the fact that your contribution room has nothing to do with your income. You don’t start accumulating RRSP room until you report earnings on your tax return, and even then you can contribute just 18% of that income. So even teens and students with part-time jobs are likely to enter their mid-twenties with minimal RRSP room. But as soon as you turn 18 years old you begin accruing TFSA contribution room regardless of how much you earn: with the annual limit now at $10,000, this year’s high school grads could have more than $50,000 of TFSA room by the time they start their first career.

That’s a boon to young hypersavers like Blair, who for now is living with his parents and able to save about half of his after-tax income, far more than the RRSP rules would allow. Because he can take advantage of the TFSA contribution room he built up while attending college, he’s able to put as much as $15,000 a year into his TFSA.


TFSA tip

Another benefit of the TFSA to young savers is that the tax savings comes when you draw down the account in retirement rather than when you make the contribution. The RRSP is almost a no-brainer for Canadians in the highest tax bracket, since their immediate refund can be close to 50% and it’s unlikely they’ll pay more tax than that in retirement. But for folks earning a modest income now with the expectation of more in the future, the TFSA is usually a better way to save: even though they forgo the immediate refund when money goes in, there’s a larger tax savings when they take it out.

Let’s consider someone like Blair who’s earning $40,000 at the beginning of his career, putting him in Ontario’s lowest tax bracket. Contributing 18% of his income ($7,200 annually) would net him a tax refund of about 20%, or $1,444. But when he later withdraws that money in retirement he’ll pay tax on it, and it’s quite likely he’ll no longer be in the lowest tax bracket. He might be receiving Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Old Age Security (OAS) benefits, and maybe an employer pension, rental income or dividends from a business he owns. If he has a 32% marginal tax rate in retirement, a $7,200 withdrawal would result in a tax bill of $2,304—over 50% more than his original refund. The lesson here is that if you’re in a higher tax bracket when you withdraw your savings than when you contributed, RRSPs are the wrong vehicle.

Now consider how the TFSA benefits Canadians who are expecting to earn higher incomes in the future. By contributing $7,200 to a TFSA instead of an RRSP, someone in a 20% tax bracket forfeits the $1,444 refund this year, but his savings will not be taxable when they’re ultimately withdrawn. If you’re in a 32% tax bracket in retirement, you would avoid that potential $2,304 tax bill you’d otherwise pay, so your net savings is $860. Moreover, the TFSA withdrawal won’t affect income-tested government benefits like OAS.

Gross income


Finally, the TFSA’s flexibility makes it ideal for young Canadians whose future includes more than just retirement. RRSPs were designed specifically to help Canadians save money and defer taxes while they were working and use that money to fund their senior years. You can withdraw the money early if you need to, but you’ll pay withholding taxes of up to 30% (these may be recoverable) and you’ll never get that contribution room back. Programs such as the Home Buyers’ Plan and the Lifelong Learning Plan allow you to borrow from your RRSP and pay it back according to a fixed schedule­—and these are still useful for those who have already socked away money in their retirement plans. But the TFSA has largely made them obsolete for younger savers.

With a TFSA you can tap your savings at any time without tax consequences, and your contribution room is restored on January 1 of the following year. You don’t even lose the additional room created by the growth of your investments. Say you maxed out your TFSA at $41,000 early this year and the investments grew to $45,000. If you withdraw that money today, you’d be able to recontribute the whole $45,000 next year. These features makes the TFSA ideal for young people saving for a down payment, a new car, a wedding, grad school or any other medium-term goal.

Blair Stiver isn’t sure exactly what the future holds in terms of career, family, home ownership and retirement. But he’s confident that his tax-free savings will give him the freedom to meet all of his goals. “I view the TFSA as possibly the only account I will ever use.”


2 comments on “TFSAs for young savers

  1. Nice article but raises some questions. In the example above you mentioned that you will pay an upfront tax of CAD 1,444 and avoid paying tax of CAD 2,304 when you retire assuming that you are in a higher tax bracket.
    Is it so simple? Why pay a single penny of tax when you could save all of it by investing in RRSP. Within 9 years, you could have earned more that 800 dollars if your investment returned 5% per year. Assuming that this youth would work for more than 30 years before retiring, the money earned in RRSP would be 6-6 times more.
    Plus, one doesn’t know what would be the tax rate in Canada after 30-35 more years.

    It doesn’t seem so simple!

    Your thoughts?


    • The calculations are multiplicative so the RRSP won’t be 6x more if you invest in the same vehicle

      for example if the marginal tax rate is 20% and we invest $7200 pre tax dollars for 30 years at 5%

      Pre tax Deposit amount =7200
      Tax rate is 20%

      Actual deposit is $5,760 = $7,200*.8

      Value in 30 years = 5,760 * 1.05^30 = 24,894

      Pretax Depsoit $7,200

      Value in 30 years = 7,200 * 1.05^30 = $31,117.99

      20% marginal tax rate at withdrawal
      tax = $31,117.99 * .2 = $6,223.60

      Net funds after withdrawal 20 % marginal tax = $31,117.99 – $6,223.60 = $24,894

      As you can see it is the SAME and NOT 6x more.

      Now lets assume you get promoted and get raises so your tax rate when you retire is 30%

      30% marginal tax rate at wiithdrawal
      tax = $31,117.99 * .3 = $9,335.40

      Net funds after withdrawal 30% marginal tax = $31,117.99 -9,335.4 = $21,782.59

      As you can see the with an increased tax rate at withdrawal the TFSA has $3,111.80 MORE!!!! thats almost 15% more with NO additional risk !!!!

      If you are starting out and expect to get raises TFSAs should be used First!!!

      TFSAs help young people starting out and middle class people the most NOT the rich like the Liberals ahve stated!

      Lets face it, the only things for sure in life are death and taxes. While taxes do go down on occasion they mostly stay the same or go up. Also unless you have no ambition and no skills as you get experience you will rise up through the ranks and get raises etc. As you get raises you will be in a higher tax bracket. These two assumptions alone make it a safe bet you will be paying more marginal taxes near retirement!


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *