Should we manage our bank stocks ourselves to save on fees?

How to stop paying high fees on bank stocks

Our bank advisor is bleeding us on bank stock fees. How do I make it stop?



Q. We have a portfolio of investments at an investment branch of a major financial institution. Our annual fees, based on the size of our portfolio, were $18,000 last year. This seems outrageous given that approximately one-third of our portfolio is sitting in bank stocks which we have no intention of ever selling.

We are retired and are in these stocks for the long haul, and are prepared to endure a bumpy ride if necessary. We, therefore, don’t wish to pay management fees on this portion of our portfolio, as it does not require any management. What is the best way to go about extricating, in kind, a portion of one’s stock holdings away from their financial manager without incurring too many fees?

– Thank you, Marion

A. There’s an easy way to do this, Marion, and the fees will be small if there are any fees at all. Here are three different approaches to consider:

The first approach is the easiest, and it’s simply to ask your advisor to not include your bank stocks in the portfolio “fee” calculation. There’s no cost to you, your advisor still has access to your investments, and all of your investments will show on one statement. Perfect!!

READ: How to mix rental income and portfolio returns in retirement

The catch: I know this is possible with some independent firms but I’m not sure it’s possible at the banks. You’ll have to ask your advisor or check the form you signed when you agreed to your “fees” and look for something that refers to “product exclusions”.

The second and third approach is to do an “in kind” partial transfer from your account to a bank or independent discount brokerage.

If you use your current bank’s discount brokerage you may get some help in completing the transfer paperwork and may get the withdrawal fee, if any, waived.

READ: Are TFSAs the best place to hold Vanguard’s new all-in-one ETFs?

If you do an in-kind transfer to an independent discount brokerage you may save a little on fees and get a little less assistance.

Before transferring your bank investments talk to your advisor and review the services they’re providing. It’s often easier for a financial planner to monitor and give advice when they have access to all of your investments, particularly in retirement.

READ: How to rebalance when some ETFs already do it themselves

Also be aware that with a lower account value you may be transferred to a different bank advisor, although with your account size you’re likely okay.

To summarize, the only fee you may have is the partial withdrawal fee. It doesn’t matter if your investments are in a RRSP/RRIF/TFSA or non-registered account. They can be transferred without any tax implications. I wish you luck Marion and hopefully you and your advisor can find a solution that works for both of you.

Allan Norman, M.Sc., CIM,, is a chartered financial planner (CFP) with Atlantis Financial/IPC Investment Corp.  This commentary is provided as a general source of information and is intended for Canadian residents only. The views and opinions expressed in this commentary may not necessarily reflect those of IPC Investment Corporation.