What to do with a sudden inheritance

Diego just received a windfall. So why is he so miserable?

  2 Premium content image

by

From the January 2015 issue of the magazine.

  2 Premium content image
A sudden windfall inheritance is disturbing Diego (Illustration by Amedeo de Palma)

A sudden inheritance is disturbing Diego. (Illustration by Amedeo de Palma)

When Diego Padilla received a phone call last year from an estate lawyer, the 34-year-old Montrealer could hardly believe what he was hearing. The message? One of Diego’s elderly uncles had died and left him $670,000 in his will. “I hadn’t seen my uncle Carlos for over 15 years so it was a huge shock,” says Diego, an environmental engineer. “Growing up, I had heard stories that he was a very shrewd businessman. So when I learned of the inheritance, I was happily surprised­—but also quite anxious.”

That’s because Diego is only recently married and is worried about tying up his newfound wealth with his wife Renata, 30, should they later divorce. Prior to his big windfall, the couple had been actively saving to buy a house in the upscale neighbourhood where they rent—Diego’s inheritance, of course, changes everything. “Part of me wants to protect this money, and the other half wants to just go for it and buy the $1-million house of our dreams,” he says. “But what if I put the inheritance money toward the purchase of a family home and Renata and I divorce in a few years. Will I lose half that money?”

Complicating matters is the fact that he and Renata are expecting a baby soon, which makes Diego feel guilty for even thinking about how to proceed. “I feel like I’m at a fork in the road. I love my wife, but I don’t know what to do with all this money.”

Family Profile: A sudden inheritanceFor now, Diego and Renata continue to rent a two-bedroom apartment in the Montreal neighbourhood they hold close to their hearts. “Both Renata’s parents and my own rented in this same neighbourhood all their lives and we grew up here too. We have no plans to leave,” says Diego, noting that he and his wife have known each other since elementary school. “If we ever bought a house, it will be here,” agrees Renata. But while the couple’s rent is modest (just $1,340 a month), the truth is that real estate prices for detached homes in their beloved stomping grounds are astronomical—from $1 million to $5 million.

Right now, the Padillas earn $120,000 a year between them, and they have about $150,000 saved in RRSPs, TFSAs and a joint bank account. They had been planning to use most of their savings to make a 20% home down payment within the next five to 10 years. Living a simple lifestyle and following an ambitious savings plan has enabled them to get far ahead financially, given their relatively young ages. “We knew it would take us several years to save up a down payment but we’re patient,” says Renata, adding that they’re still putting $24,000 of their annual incomes into RRSPs and TFSAs.

Diego’s $670,000 inheritance, of course, now has the couple contemplating immediate home ownership—but only in fits and starts, as Diego vacillates on what course of action he should take. Believe it or not, his apprehension about what to do with hundreds of thousands of dollars of free money has even made for some sleepless nights in their household. “Honestly,” says Renata, “the inheritance complicates things for us.”

That the couple should even find themselves in such a position—deciding what do with Diego’s golden ticket—is fairly remarkable. Both Diego and Renata grew up modestly, and while there was always enough money to go around, both of their families shunned frivolous or unnecessary spending. Education, however, was a big priority, and it was at the University of Sherbrooke—Diego for engineering, Renata for business administration—that the couple’s relationship morphed from friendship into something much more special. “We discovered that we get along well and generally agree on everything,” says Diego. Three years ago, the couple had a big church wedding and then moved into their present rental apartment, where there’s now a lot of teeth-gnashing over what do with a big chunk of money.

Family Profile: A sudden inheritanceRenata, who is sensitive to Diego’s concerns about his inheritance, has suggested combining the money they’ve already saved together with a smaller portion of her husband’s newfound wealth—just enough to enable them to put a 40% down payment on a house (say $400,000 or so), and then mortgage the rest. “I like the idea of both of us contributing money to the purchase of a home,” says Renata. “I want Diego to always feel his inheritance is his own and whatever he decides is fine with me.”

A different option Diego is considering is to simply keep going with their original plan of saving up for a down payment of 20% with money from their job incomes. In the meantime, the couple would continue to rent, and Diego would invest his $670,000 inheritance on his own, thereby leaving it safely set aside for future use. That option, however, leaves him wondering about the right way to invest the money. “I’ve picked some bank stocks on my own recently,” says Diego, who has been reading up on investing for several months now. “However, I’ve realized that I don’t like a lot of volatility and I’d kick myself if I lost the money in a market crash. So if we decided to invest this money instead of buying a home, I’d probably need an adviser’s help to manage it.” But even that decision makes him anxious because he’s not sure how to pick a qualified professional. “Right now, I think markets are very high so I feel paralyzed. I don’t want to make a mistake with any of our savings and investments.”

Diego’s lack of confidence in managing the money then brings his conundrum full circle: Should he just buy the house outright and be done with it? It’s a simple choice, he says, not to mention a solid investment for their future. “The money will be safely tucked into the equity in my home. I like that,” he says. “The risk, of course, is if Renata and I divorce and I lose half the money. That thought keeps me up at night.” And so the cycle continues.

Thankfully, Renata and Diego have a pleasant diversion from all of this indecision over money: the impending birth of their first child. Whatever Diego decides to do with the money, says Renata, is ultimately not a big concern. “We’re lucky,” she says. “We live very simply and don’t even spend what we earn now. Plus, our daycare bills will be tiny because we have two sets of grandparents a few blocks away anxious to watch the baby when I return to work.”

Thinking about all that he’s blessed to have in his life makes Diego realize it’s now time to make a definitive decision about what to do with his inheritance—for his own peace of mind, as well as his wife’s. “We have a really nice life together now. I’m lucky to have found Renata. I don’t want to mess that up.”

What the experts say

Diego and Renata Padilla have a lot of hopes and dreams. With a new baby on the way as well as an unexpected $670,000 inheritance, it’s not uncommon for the young couple to feel uncertain about how to proceed. “Diego is very risk-averse,” says Ayana Forward, a certified financial planner with Ryan Lamontagne Inc. in Ottawa. “But doing nothing with the money would be a missed opportunity.”

Tatiana Terekhova, a certified divorce financial analyst with Fairsplit Inc. in Oakville, Ont., agrees. She also stresses that even though Diego’s greatest fear is that his marriage will end and he’ll lose his inheritance, the truth is that with a child on the way his relationship with his spouse will continue indefinitely. “It’s possible to do nice things for your family, while at the same time protecting a portion of your inheritance for yourself.” Here’s what the Padillas should do.

Family Profile: A sudden inheritanceBuy the house sooner. The Padillas were planning to buy a home even before Diego received his inheritance. But they were planning to do it in five to 10 years when they had saved up a 20% down payment. Moving that purchase up and buying the house in two to three years is the right thing to do. “They should continue saving as much as they can together from their own incomes and when they have $200,000 saved up—in two years or so—they should buy the house,” says Terekhova, adding that the additional $200,000 required to make a 40% down payment will come from Diego’s inheritance.

If Diego is hesitant to do this, he needs to appreciate the bigger picture. Putting some of his inheritance toward the purchase of a home will be crucial if he wants to maintain a happy marriage—not to mention diversify his investments. All of our experts believe it’s important that Diego show some generosity to his wife. “If he doesn’t contribute any part of the inheritance to the purchase of the home, it will always be the elephant in the room,” says Terekhova. “That would cause more strife in their marriage than simply sharing some of it.”

However, Diego will need to keep in mind that if they divorce, he could lose some of his inheritance money. In most Canadian provinces, proceeds from the sale of the family home are split 50-50, regardless of where the money came from. In Quebec, inheritance money is protected, but he would have to prove that’s where his down payment contribution came from. “He can get a notarized document stating explicitly that he made a contribution from his inheritance towards the purchase of the matrimonial home that is being registered in both their names,” says Caroline Nalbantoglu, president of CNal Financial Planning in Montreal. Even then, a lawyer could order him to split that money with his wife in certain situations, so there’s no guarantee.

Divorce issues aside, Diego and Renata should feel good about this plan because it ensures they’re sharing the responsibility of the purchase and ongoing mortgage together. “It’s important for the two of them to feel that they are both contributing,” says Terekhova. “Sure, they could buy the house for cash now and be mortgage-free with a $1-million home, but then what do they have to strive for? They’re only in their 30s. It’s working together that will keep their relationship healthy.”

With a $400,000 down payment, the Padillas will be able to carry their $600,000 mortgage comfortably using only their salaries. “Children change your life,” says Nalbantoglu. “Some of the money saved from lower restaurant and vacation costs can be used to offset higher home maintenance expenses.”

Invest the rest. Diego should keep the remaining $470,000 in a self-directed investment account. That way, it will remain his—even if they get divorced. “Just maintain a clear paper trail that this is his inheritance money,” says Forward. Diego should also find an adviser to help him manage his money. “He likes investing, but emotionally, he panics,” says Forward. He can search for a planner at moneysense.ca/planners and interview two or three before deciding who he will hire. “He should pay attention to fees and designations, and have a thorough risk assessment done,” says Forward. Once Diego has found someone he’s comfortable with, he should put the money away for a long-term goal, like retirement. “Even with a low-risk portfolio invested 50% in bonds and 50% in stocks, an average net annual return of 4% is attainable with very little risk,” says Terekhova.

Don’t forget taxes. Interest and dividends from the inheritance will be a tax liability for him. Diego should top up his RRSP and TFSA, if he has any allowable contribution room, to mitigate some of the taxes payable in the years ahead.

Review their wills. The Padillas need to update their wills, name a power of attorney and choose a guardian for their child. They should also pay attention to one other detail. “Diego needs to specify who he’d like to bequeath his inheritance money to in the investment account, because if he doesn’t name Renata specifically in the will, she won’t get it,” says Terekhova. “Or, he may choose to leave it to his child. It’s totally up to him.”

Going forward, Renata can keep investing $900 a month in her own RRSP as she’s been doing all along. This will be her retirement nest egg. As for their $1-million principal residence, it will likely keep going up in value by 2% or 3% a year. “Those gains will be totally tax-free,” says Nalbantoglu. “By their early 60s, they’ll have a house worth $2 million or more, a retirement nest egg for Diego worth $1.2 million and about $650,000 for Renata in her RRSP. If they do all this, they will look back at this time in their lives, and at Diego’s inheritance, as truly a wonderful gift.”

 

 

2 comments on “What to do with a sudden inheritance

  1. he knew her all his life, marries her and thinks about divorce? i think SHE should leave him!

    Reply

  2. He should get divorced now and save himself some time an money

    Reply

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *