How pets can reduce the value of your home

By Romana King on May 23, 2019
Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

Expect a huge cleaning bill or a lower sale price

This article is 4 years old. Some details may be outdated.

Photo by Matthew Henry on Unsplash

Selling your home? Got a pet? Then expect either a big cleaning bill or a big reduction on your sale price. “Pets impact home sales in several ways,” explained Mark Santoyo of Chicago’s RE/MAX Loyalty. “The main concern with pets is their effect on a home’s cleanliness and its smell. If a home is nicely cleaned and free of pet odours, the presence of pets is rarely an issue. However, if there is pet hair everywhere, strong pet odour in the house or pet waste around the yard, it can increase the time needed to sell the property and reduce its value.” Worse yet, you may be shutting down a potential sale to a fairly substantial segment of the market. It’s estimated that 20% to 30% of young adults will react to an airborne allergen, such as pet dander. While studies show that early exposure to animals is beneficial, the prevalence of other medical conditions, such as asthma, hay fever, will also influence an allergic response. A Swedish study found that 40% of kids with asthma reacted to cats, 34% reacted to dogs and 28% reacted to horses. Animal allergies are a common concern, and buyers who have them can be easily turned off if a house has pets, explains David Scott of RE/MAX Valley Realtors in Roscoe, Illinois. “Buyers occasionally are sensitive enough that they ask not to see homes where certain pets, typically cats or dogs, are residents. Other buyers will ask to leave a home immediately if they smell strong or foul pet odours,” Scott said. Of course, many buyers have pets of their own and often show greater tolerance. But it’s not just odour or pet hair that’s a problem. Yellow or dying grass in the front or backyard, half-chewed toys littered in yards or across rooms, as well as open or smelly litter boxes can prompt concerns, even in pet-loving buyers. That’s because problems associated with pets can last for years, says Damian Ciszek of RE/MAX 10 in Chicago. “If pets urinated in the house, the odour can linger indefinitely, and pets can do lasting damage to the woodwork by scratching or chewing,” says Ciszek. So what should pet owners do to be sure Rover and Fluffy don’t negatively impact the sale of their home? RE/MAX brokers offer five straightforward bits of advice:

→ Clean the place, especially any rugs or carpeting, thoroughly before putting the home on the market, which may mean calling in professionals. And don’t forget the air vents. Once the house is clean, keep it that way.

→ Pet owners often don’t notice the odours caused by their animals, so it’s best to ask your broker or friend if odours are noticeable.

→ If animals have urinated in the house, replace the affected carpeting or flooring, eliminating the odour at its source.

→ Ideally, remove pets from the home while the house is on the market. If that’s impractical, either take the pets out during showings or keep them confined in a small room or crate.

Santoyo added that pets also can be a distraction. Some people are phobic about animals. Others adore them. Either group can have a hard time ignoring a pet if it is wandering around the home. “Do you want a buyer playing with your cat for 15 minutes or seeing the best features of your home?” he asked. To help you get highest sale price for your home, consider spending money to fix the problems. “It may not be cheap,” says Ciszek, “but it will make money for you in the long run.” As a way to illustrate his point, Ciszek states that an animal-damaged home is like a home that hasn’t been updated in 30 years. Scott estimates that for every dollar a potential seller will need to spend to clean or remediate a pet problem, they’ll reduce their bid price by $2 to $3. For example, if it would cost $10,000 to replace the floors the buyer will reduce their offer by $20,000 to $30,000. “If you want to achieve maximum value on your home sale, it’s best to correct the flaws yourself, rather than offering credits to the buyer,” added Scott.

Comments Cancel reply

Mike E. says:

September 23, 2020 at 2:10 am

yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh, with 60% of people owning pets, this is a bit fear mongering. Yeah, you might get less hits, or may not get a few thousand less, but we sold our home that had 5 cats and 2 dogs and sold it within a weak for full market value.

This is akin to the realtors who PANIC about you now moving all your stuff into storage and showing the house like a neighborhood “demo” house. Realistically, you may sell in a month or so longer, or lose a few bucks, but by the time you spend paying thousands to professionally clean a house multiple times over the summer sale time, and replace every bit of damage, you’re about even.

Reply
Ptk says:

November 22, 2022 at 2:57 am

We are looking at a house that had 3 cats and 3 dogs. It is extremely filthy – carpets, walls, HVAC – so I don’t believe this is fear mongering. As stated in the article, it depends on the perspective and mine is coming from a buyers. Only considering the house because it is our dream location, but only considering the house beginning with a very low-ball offer. I’d say it also depends on the pet owners and how much they kept up the property – the one I am seeing was very poor.

Reply