If you lack the investment knowledge, time or inclination to manage a handful of ETFs, this is a great option. For fees as low as 0.2% of funds invested per year, you get access to the whole world of stocks, bonds and sometimes other asset classes. You wouldn’t have to weary yourself following the market gyrations we’ve seen so far in 2025—just set it and forget it. By automatically rebalancing allocations to domestic and foreign stocks and bonds, these one-decision ETFs reduce the work required by a DIY investor to stay on top of the ebbs and flows of the underlying holdings.
Best all-in-one ETFs 2025
That said, a couple of our Best ETFs in Canada judges explained why they weren’t big fans.
“Retail investors are better served by buying the component pieces themselves,” argues ETF judging panellist Mark Yamada, president and CEO of PUR Investing. The management expenses for Canadian and U.S. equity, as well as fixed income funds, are typically lower than for all-in-one ETFs, and “the higher fees for auto-rebalancing aren’t worth it.”
ETF judging panellist Aman Raina of Sage Investors says he’s not in favour of using any of the major asset allocation funds right now because they skew so heavily towards North American equities. This has been the asset class most exposed to tariff-related volatility this year.
Still, one-decision ETFs can come in handy even for more engaged investors in smaller accounts. Investors using tax-free savings accounts (TFSAs) and/or registered education savings plans (RESPs) may find it makes less sense to be juggling multiple investments and enjoy all-in-one ETFs. They can also make it easy for investors who are depositing or withdrawing money regularly from their accounts so that they don’t have to figure out what to buy or sell.
The results of the judging best ETFs exercise, with iShares Core Equity Portfolio ETF (XEQT) on top and seven other funds close behind, illustrates how there’s not much to choose between the major fund companies—iShares, BMO, Vanguard, TD and Global X—in this category. We ended up resorting to a tiebreaker vote to come up with the final two choices listed below: iShares’ Core Balanced ETF Portfolio (XBAL) and TD’s unique Growth ETF Portfolio (TGRO).
What’s more important than the brand is that you pick the asset allocation most appropriate for your risk tolerance. That is, consider an all-equity fund for long-term capital appreciation and something with a higher fixed-income allocation, like XBAL, for moderate risk. And regardless of your risk tolerance, if you might need the money sooner, a lower stock allocation may be appropriate.
Watch: Asset-Allocation ETFs
Get free MoneySense financial tips, news & advice in your inbox.
Michael is a financial writer and editor in Duncan, B.C. He’s a former managing editor of Canadian Business and editorial director of Canada Wide Media. He also writes for The Globe and Mail and BCBusiness.
