4 ways to cope with low investment returns

If you rely on historical returns to guide your financial plan, then you may want to rethink your strategy. As I argued recently, investors need to brace themselves for substantially lower returns versus what they are accustomed to. It’s a helpless feeling—but investors aren’t completely powerless in this situation. We can distill your choices in this situation into four options:

Brace for lower returns

Invest (save) more while you’re working
Invest more aggressively
Accept a lower standard of living (income stream) in retirement
Retire later

Most people can mix these variables and aim to tweak them to suit their circumstances. Life is about trade-offs and whatever you choose ought to reflect both your situation and your values. I might add that the obvious admonition to lower your costs should go without saying.

Save more in your working years

In working with about 100 families from across the country, I can tell you that the appetite for putting aside more money is still quite low. Anyone in the lowest tax bracket (under about $45,000) needn’t save much—and ought to be investing in a TFSA when they do save. Wealthy people (say those with a personal income over $150,000) should aim to maximize both RRSPs and TFSAs. Obviously, the more you make, the more you should be willing and able to save. Setting aside 10% of earned income is a bare minimum and if you want a comfortable retirement then you will likely need to set 15% of your income. But if you plan to retire early then you’ll likely need to set aside 20% of your income to make that happen.

Get aggressive

As a general rule, most people’s tolerance for risk is fairly stable over time. If you’re counting on your portfolio for income then you’re likely to be more sensitive to the lower returns because retirees can’t capitalize on market dips the way people who are still working can. But that said, I don’t generally counsel people to invest any more aggressively than they have in the past—assuming their risk tolerance was properly calibrated in the first place. This is a good time for investors to reexamine their risk profile and to consider whether they can take on more risk. If you are comfortable taking on more risk then consider increasing equity exposure by an additional 10%. One of my favourite phrases for this decade has been “70/30 is the new 60/40”. Of course, if you’re working with an advisor that answers to a compliance department, a 10% variance from your long-term goal is likely all that will be tolerated, so don’t go overboard.

Lower expectations

Accepting a lesser quality of life is the sort of thing that no one willingly chooses. For some retirees reading this, however, it might be the only remaining workable solution. Of course, this should only be a last resort if all else fails.

Hold off on retirement

The ultimate guide to the Canadian Couch Potato Portfolio

That leaves us with the option of retiring later in life than we may have originally expected. To me, this is the easy winner in the great retirement multiple choice contest. First off, most people are living much longer than earlier generations have. Life expectancy has been increasing by about two years per decade for a few decades now. In short, someone who is 30 years younger than you might reasonably expect to live six years longer than you do – all else being equal. It’s simply not reasonable to expect to live longer than ever before, but not have any more money than ever before. I’d like to encourage people to split those extra years of their lives equally between work and play. For every decade that you are older, consider working (and playing) a year longer because you’ll likely be living two years longer than someone who is a decade older than you. The rule of thumb that I’m fond of is to use the decade of your birth to be the last number in your retirement age. Those born in the 50s might retire at 65, people born in the 60s might retire at 66, while people born in the 70s might retire at 67…and so on. Due to increased life expectancy, it is entirely possible that even with later retirement ages, future generations may spend more years in retirement than any generation before them.

Bonus option: Ease into retirement

More evidence is coming forward that people who stay engaged in the workforce longer, generally live longer after they retire—assuming you love what you do. If possible, you might want to consider easing into retirement. I was born in the 60s and expect to be working just as hard at age 65 as I am now, but I plan to retire before I turn 70. Not everyone can transition to part time work en route to full retirement, but it provides the double benefit of maintaining connectivity and delaying portfolio withdrawals (even if saving is no longer practical as a part-timer). A big part of why people expect returns to be lower is demographics. Fewer of us are working and the number of savers is about to surpass the number of borrowers. Rates may stay low for the rest of our lives. With debt levels (both personal and public) at all-time highs, there’s really no room left for further fiscal stimulus, either. Low growth is the new normal. Your planning choices should reflect that reality. John J. De Goey CFP, CIM, FELLOW OF FPSC is a Portfolio Manager with Industrial Alliance Securities (iAS) and the author of The Professional Financial Advisor IV. The views expressed are not necessarily shared by iAS.

Comments Cancel reply

A woman using the MoneySense Finder tool at her work-from-home desk

ETFs

Buying ETFs in Canada Tool: The MoneySense ETF Screener

Which ETFs should you invest in? Which ones best suit your risk tolerance? What about personal ethics? Check out...

Buying ETFs in Canada Tool: The MoneySense ETF Screener

Retired Money

Who you gonna trust: Barry Ritholtz or Jim Cramer?

A trio of new books from notable (and notorious) authors offer fresh insights on retirement investing.

Who you gonna trust: Barry Ritholtz or Jim Cramer?

The exterior of the TMX is seen in Toronto, Wednesday, Nov. 1, 2023.

ETFs

Covered call ETFs have high yields but come with a trade-off

Covered call ETFs are gaining popularity in Canada, offering higher income for investors—but experts warn of higher fees and...

Covered call ETFs have high yields but come with a trade-off

Wealthsimple's chief executive officer Michael Katchen is photographed at the company's Toronto office on Wednesday, July 30, 2025.

News

Stock news for investors: Iamgold expands, Teck advances merger talks, and Wealthsimple hits $100B milestone

Canadian markets saw a mix of expansion, earnings gains and challenges this week, with mining, logistics, fintech and forestry...

Stock news for investors: Iamgold expands, Teck advances merger talks, and Wealthsimple hits $100B milestone

Crypto

Cryptocurrency exchange Cryptomus fined record $177M by Fintrac

Fintrac says the Vancouver-based exchange failed to report thousands of suspicious and high-risk transactions, marking the largest enforcement action...

Cryptocurrency exchange Cryptomus fined record $177M by Fintrac