Segregated funds: A cracked nest egg

“Seg” funds no longer make much sense.



From the October 2008 issue of the magazine.


If you’re a senior citizen, a small business owner or simply a cautious investor, you’ve probably heard sales pitches for what are known as segregated funds. Our advice? Steer clear.

Seg funds are offered by insurance companies; at first glance, they look much like mutual funds. But seg funds impose very high fees— as much as 4% a year, which is substantially more than the 2% to 2.5% that most mutual funds charge, and four to 10 times what index funds bill you.

So why would anyone buy a seg fund? A major appeal used to be that creditors could not seize seg funds if you went bust. So if you had concerns about your financial health, or ran a small business in a risky industry, seg funds provided you with a lockbox that your creditors couldn’t get into if things went wrong.

But that rationale for buying seg funds has just disappeared. Thanks to recent changes to the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, creditors can no longer get at any money you hold in your registered retirement savings plan (RRSP), registered retirement income fund (RRIF) and deferred profit sharing plan. As long as you placed your money in one of those plans 12 months or more before declaring bankruptcy, it’s off limits to the people you owe. So you no longer need seg funds to build a firewall between you and the bill collectors.

The companies that sell seg funds aren’t going gently into the night. They are touting other benefits from seg funds. For instance, most seg funds come with a guarantee that ensures you or your beneficiaries get back your initial investment at the end of 10 years or when you die. That can be attractive to people worried about a stock market plunge. In addition, seg funds don’t have to pass through probate when you die, which means that your heirs save on probate fees.

But none of those benefits is worth the high fees, says Marc Lamontagne, a certified financial planner with Ryan Lamontagne Inc. in Ottawa. He notes that the stock market nearly always rises over the period of 10 years, which makes the 10-year guarantee on most seg funds of dubious value.”I don’t think there’s one 10-year period in history when paying the extra fees for segregated funds would have been worth it,” he asserts. “You get better returns using a mix of low-fee mutual funds and index funds. That gives you the best of both worlds, especially for anyone under60.”

The death guarantee and the lack of probate fees is most attractive to investors over the age of 70. But Norm Rothery, chief investment strategist at Dan Hallett & Associates Inc. and the founder of, wouldn’t recommend seg funds even to the elderly. “The guarantee is useless and can be obtained much more cheaply,” says Rothery. “Just buy a GIC and put the interest you receive in riskier investments. That will guarantee your principal. You don’t need seg funds for that.”

24 comments on “Segregated funds: A cracked nest egg

  1. Personally, I only recommend them to elderly single people who need the probate benefits. The average time to probate a will in Canada is around 18 months, so the prospect of having your beneficiaries possibly waiting more than a year to receive the benefit of your estate is not something most of these people want. Being able to name a beneficiary generally results in death benefits paid within 2-3 weeks, and the payment is private, too. Because it bypasses probate, it is not registered with your provincial gov't, where others can see the details of the will proceeds.

    As for the guarantees, I agree with the author – the 10 years guarantee is useless unless you are investing in very high risk funds, which typically is not the risk tolerance of a retired person anyway. However, if it provides the investor with some sense of comfort despite the high MERs, then that is the client's decision if their peace of mind is worth the higher cost of the product.

  2. Most mutual funds do have a positive return after 10 years just like most segregated funds. This is good if your client passes away at the END of 10 years. Once you've delivered death claims to a widow in a down market who's husband had mutual funds and segregated funds with you, you would not be writting this article.

  3. Actually a rather silly little article — like for instance what about creditor protection for a business man's non-registered cash? Only Seg funds work for that.

    And silly idea of putting money in a GIC and investing the interest to protect the principle
    Example $100,000 in a GIC at 4% WOW $4,000 to invest in equities — when the whole $100,000 could be invested and protected with a SEG fund.

    How about this nonsense that all funds recover within 10 years. Folks invested in NASDAQ in 2000 are still only at about 40% of the original investment–unless like my clients they had Seg funds in which case all their original investments have been recovered. Those poor souls who owned Mutual Funds of the same investments won't ever see their investment come back (So much for the poppycock that all funds are OK after 10 years!!!)

  4. glad to be one of the visitants on this awesome website : D.

  5. since loosing my vinyl decks in a house fire, I have decided to buy virtual dj. It took abit of getting used to but now I know how to use it, all I can say is wow. I very much doubt that I will go back to normal decks now I have this

  6. I seemed to be aware about this previously, but nonetheless there was clearly several helpful bits which finalized the picture for me, thanks a lot!

  7. That seems very good but i am just still less than certain that I like it. Anyways will look more into it and choose for myself! :)

  8. I welcome all comments, but i am possessing problems undering anything you could be seeking to say

  9. Dear webmaster, I think this post will be a nice read for my blog readers too, could you please allow me to post it on my blog?

  10. I was totally essaying this particular information awhile. Soon there after all the time such as uninterrupted Googleing, at long last I got it in your site . I enquire whats precisely the absence like Google strategy the dont social station this amazing sort of informative blog posts in elevation of each and every list . The exact the best content are full similar to garbage .

  11. Hey there, You’ve done a great job. I will certainly digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I’m sure they will be benefited from this website.

  12. Pingback: spring break ideas

  13. I seemed to be aware of this previously, however there were several helpful bits that completed the picture for me, thanks!

  14. I was aware about this already, but nevertheless there was clearly some helpful pieces that concluded the image for me personally, thanks!

  15. Alright, that’s a nice beginning however i’m going to look into that a bit more. Will let you know just what else there really is.

  16. Fine, it really is a nice beginning but i’m going to look into that a great deal more. Will let you know just what else there is.

  17. Well, it’s excellent, however think about the other choices we’ve got here? Would you mind publishing one more post regarding these too? Kudos!

  18. I like the valuable info you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your weblog and check again here regularly. I’m quite sure I’ll learn plenty of new stuff right here! Good luck for the next!

  19. Hello, I love your website. You are a great writer. The highest quality nap mat on the web. Your one stop shop for any sleep mat.

  20. I have been searching just about everywhere on information about this. Thanks a lot.