Q. I have recently sold some paintings from my parents’ art collection. The money is more than I expected. I will be retiring in the next year or two. I have an RRSP and TFSA. I can put the max in those, but am not sure if that is the right thing to do. Also, I will be sharing the money with my already retired brother who is collecting money from QPP and will be starting OAS soon.
My current income is $39,000 gross per year. My assets are about $ 100,000. I have no real estate, no debt, and no dependents. Is this capital gains and how do I minimize the tax I will pay and not jeopardize my brother’s income?
Thank you, Roy M.
A. Hi Roy. Thanks for the question. As per the Canada Revenue Agency, when an item(s) is used for personal use by the owner/someone related to the owner it is termed “personal use property.” From your description, the art you sold falls into this category. When this property is sold, or when the owner of the personal use property passes, a capital gain or loss can arise.
When determining the amount of the gain or loss, if the cost of the property was below $1,000 it is pushed to $1,000. Additionally, if the amount received from the sale is less than $1,000, the amount considered to have been received is pushed to $1,000. This essentially means that no capital gain will arise when the personal use property is sold for less than or equal to $1,000. Since a painting fits into the sub-category of “listed personal property” if it is sold at a loss, the loss can only be offset against capital gains that arose from the sale of other listed personal property but it can be carried back for three years or forward for seven years.
Note that you do not add the capital gain itself to your income, rather, you add the taxable capital gain which is equal to 50% of the capital gain.
Example: Let’s say the painting was purchased for $5,000 and your cost was $2,000, your capital gain would be $3,000 but your taxable capital gain would only be $1,500; this $1,500 taxable capital gain would be added to your taxable income and taxed at your marginal rate.
To address your question, there is not a way to shelter a capital gain you may have incurred from tax since the gain was not incurred in a TFSA. Additionally, if you were the owner of the painting, then you will have to pay the tax on any taxable capital gain involved, not your brother so it will not affect the taxes he will need to pay.
However, if you received this art from your parents’ estate, and if a taxable capital gain has arisen previously this could mean you may not have a taxable capital gain or the taxable capital gain may be minimal, for example:
For instance, let’s say your parents paid $2,000 for the painting and when they passed it was worth $5,000. Similar to the example above, the taxable capital gain would be $1,500 which may have been paid in their estate taxes. If this taxable capital gain has been accounted for your new adjusted cost base would be $5,000 meaning if you sold the painting for $5,000 there would be no capital gain incurred.
If you are looking to save the proceeds to use later in retirement then I would suggest putting the money into a TFSA to shelter the growth on that money from taxes.
Andrew Fox is a certified financial planner with Fox Wealth Mangement in Calgary.
MORE ABOUT ASK AN INVESTMENT EXPERT:
- How to bridge from early retirement to taking a pension
- Transfer assets to your TFSA with minimal tax impact
- How to pick the right bond ETFs for rising interest rates
- Can a portfolio of just one ETF make sense?
- Is an RRSP worth it if you’re retiring abroad?