CPP more costly than other public sector pensions

As the largest plan, it also has the highest expense ratio



Online only.

(Fraser Institute)

(Fraser Institute)

The Canada Pension Plan (CPP) is more costly than five public sector pension plans, according to a new report by the Fraser Institute.

The report compared the total costs, including investment and administrative of the CPP with five large public sector plans based in Ontario, including: the Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan (OTPP), the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System (OMERS), the Healthcare of Ontario Pension Plan (HOOPP), the Ontario Pension Board (OPB), and the OPTrust.

Go DIY on your own CPP »

It found that the CPP, which is the largest plan with $269 billion of assets, had the highest expense ratio at 1.07% of its assets on average for the whole period between 2009 and 2014. The OTPP, the next largest plan at $154 billion of assets, had the fourth highest average expense ratio (0.63%).

“In fact, there may be diseconomies of scale for larger public pension plans because of the complexity of implementing their investment strategies, which include contracting out for external experts – a practice that has become increasingly popular, with plans investing more in non-traditional assets such as real estate, infrastructure, and private equity,” said the report.

“These more aggressive investment strategies raise costs. Whether they are justified by higher rates of return will not be known for decades, and depend on whether the assumption that markets have mispriced these assets is borne out.”

This article was originally published on Benefits Canada.

One comment on “CPP more costly than other public sector pensions

  1. This article is misleading. The CPP is not comparable to other “public” pension funds (which are not public in the same sense of the word). The CPP is partially funded, has a much larger and more diffuse population with much lower average accrued benefits, and a big disability assessment division, all of which inflate admin costs as a share of the fund when compared to the more fully-funded, relatively homogeneous and higher benefit Ontario public sector pension funds the study uses for comparison. They actually note in passing that the per member admin cost of CPP is actually well below that of the other plans.
    Nothing more than another Fraser hack “study” dressed up as rigorous research.


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *