Canadian stocks look cheap, and 4 other chart insights for 2019
Plus, will interest rates keep rising?
Plus, will interest rates keep rising?
For the fifth year in a row Maclean’s asked dozens of economists, analysts and money managers to each pick a chart they believe will be important in the year ahead, and to explain why. You can see the full collection of important charts for 2019 here. We’ve selected five charts of particular importance to investors, about stock market valuations, fixed income, the balance sheets at Canadian banks and the interplay between rising interest rates and economic growth.
David Rosenberg, the chief economist at Gluskin Sheff and Associates, argues that Canadian stocks look incredibly cheap right now:
Rosenberg: “The macro news in Canada may indeed be bad, but that bad news is likely already in the price. Consider for a moment that there has been no bull market north of the border this cycle as there was in the United States. The Canadian stock market is no higher now than it was in the summer of 2008—ten years of nothing but a whole lot of volatility and your reinvested dividend in the blue-chip banks.
Yet corporate earnings have risen more than 30 per cent over this time frame, with nothing to show for it from a market price standpoint. In other words, the Canadian stock market is cheap. Dirt cheap. The forward price-earnings multiple (p/e) is beginning to resemble that of an emerging market, and no, despite our challenges, we are not anywhere close to being an emerging market. Not yet, anyway.
RELATED: As rates rise, dividend stocks could suffer
That p/e multiple has compressed all the way down to a mere 13.3 times, the lowest it has been in well over five years and the two-and-a-half percentage point discount that the S&P/TSX Composite Index trades at currently vis-à-vis the S&P 500 is the widest the valuation gap has been since June 2004 (normally, both markets trade with the same multiple).
Canadian bears may want to dig into the history books because in the year that followed, the TSX rallied 16 per cent versus 4.5 per cent for the S&P 500. That was as tough a sell then as it is today, but either you believe in reversion-to-the-mean, or you don’t.”
Kurt Reiman, the chief investment strategist at Blackrock Canada, believes that short-term government bonds have a place in investors’ portfolios right now:
Reiman: “During much of the post-financial-crisis period, yields on shorter-maturity bonds failed to compensate investors for inflation. In other words, real interest rates were negative. After successive rate hikes by the Bank of Canada and the U.S. Federal Reserve, short-term interest rates now offer investors a positive real yield, which creates competition for capital and has likely contributed to recent bouts of stock market volatility. We think allocations to short-term government bonds benefit investors in three important respects: they provide higher yields than cash, they offer lower interest rate risk than longer-maturity bonds, and they provide ballast for the portfolio during periods of elevated uncertainty and financial market volatility.”
RELATED: How should your asset allocation change over time?
Anthony Scilipoti, the CEO of Veritas Investment Research, warns that higher retail credit risk is around the corner, and that could pose a problem for bank balance sheets:
Scilipoti: “Since the financial crisis, Canadians have increased their indebtedness by over 50 per cent. Yet as a proportion of disposable income, the costs to carry said debt has remained constant.
Unfortunately, the regime of low interest rates is about to change. According to the BOC, the weekly effective interest rate for households, which is a weighted-average of mortgage and non-mortgage interest rates, reached 3.9 per cent in October 2018; the highest rate since March 2009. As higher rates flow through to outstanding retail credit, primarily from rate resets on fixed and variable rate mortgages, Canadian households are expected to experience rising DSRs for the first time since the financial crisis.
The BOC’s June 2018 Financial System Review analysis of the impact of higher rates from fixed mortgages renewals implies that the household DSR is expected to rise to around 14.9 per cent, matching the peak DSR reached in 2007. The rising DSR will put pressure on consumer spending, and based on our analysis, is a reliable leading indicator of higher delinquency rates and credit losses for Canadian banks. With the DSR already at 14.5 per cent in Q2-18, we caution investors that higher retail credit risk is around the corner and that investors should closely monitor their exposure to banks dependent on Canadian retail lending.”
READ: A nearly $40,000 TFSA all-in on Canadian dividend stocks
David Wolf is a portfolio manager at Fidelity Investments, and he notes that historically real mortgage interest rates have an inverse relationship to economic growth, meaning when rates have risen, growth has slowed within a year:
Wolf: “Interest rates have been going up. Canadians are more indebted than ever. Putting the two together, the period ahead is likely to be challenging for the Canadian economy. This chart puts a picture to that, showing that changes in Canadians’ real mortgage interest burden (inverted in the chart) leads growth in GDP by nearly a year—in other words, the higher that burden, the weaker the economy will tend to be. The historical relationship suggests the risk of recession in Canada in 2019, a risk that will intensify if interest rates continue to rise.”
READ: Why Canadians invest too much at home
Derek Holt, vice president and head of Scotiabank Capital Markets Economics, isn’t worried about rising rates causing a recession, and he sees both the Bank of Canada and Federal Reserve continuing to tighten rates in 2019:
Holt: “Neither the Bank of Canada nor the Federal Reserve is on the verge of driving their respective economies into recession through rate hikes. The chart shows the inflation-adjusted policy interest rate in Canada and the U.S. over time with shaded vertical bars representing recession periods. The so-called ‘real’ rate is either about zero (U.S.) or about -0.5 per cent (Canada). Never before has either country entered recession driven by over-tightening of monetary policy with the real policy rate as low as it is today. As such, monetary policy remains stimulative to growth in both countries. Against guidance that 2019 will lead to interest rate relief for borrowers on such recession fears, it would be prudent and responsible for borrowers to prepare for further rate hikes within economies that have essentially exhausted slack and that are generating firm inflation pressures.”
A lookback at the performance of the MoneySense Canadian...
With inflation, war and COVID, what are your options...
Each year, crypto mining uses huge amounts of energy...
Joe wants to transfer his 50% ownership of a...