TFSA vs RRSP: How to decide between the two
Here are five factors to consider when making your choice.
The best TFSAs in Canada for 2022
Presented By
CPP Investments | Investissements RPC
Photo by Arif Riyanto on Unsplash
One of the most common questions out there is whether to invest in a registered retirement savings plan (RRSP) or a tax-free savings account (TFSA). Both will help you save, and save on taxes, but each works in different ways. Understanding these investments will help you know when to use one or the other—and when you can use both in tandem.
What is a TFSA?
First introduced to Canadians in 2009, the TFSA has proven to be very popular. Each year, you get an allotment of $6,000 available for your TFSA, which means that you can put that amount away, plus any rollover from previous years (assuming you were 18 or older in 2009, you have a lifetime limit of $69,500 as of 2020). This money has already been taxed—you contribute to a TFSA from your net income—so there’s no tax break at the time of contribution. But any gains you earn in a TFSA—whether it’s from a savings account, a high-growth index fund or another investment product—aren’t subject to capital gains tax, so you won’t owe any tax on your earnings when you make a withdrawal.
What is an RRSP?
A registered retirement savings plan, or RRSP, allows you to invest up to 18% per year of your gross income, or $26,500—whichever is less—without paying income tax on that money. (If you invest with after-tax dollars, the tax will be refunded after you file your income tax return for that contribution year.)
In this way, an RRSP allows you to defer your taxes while saving for retirement. The most important thing to understand is that you will pay tax on this money once you withdraw it. The idea is that, because you will be retired, you will be in a lower tax bracket than during your high-earning years, and so will pay less tax overall because you invested in an RRSP.
TFSA vs RRSP: Which is better?
The “best” investment is going to depend on your individual financial situation and goals. Remember: with a TFSA, you pay tax on money you’ve earned before you make a contribution; and with an RRSP you get a tax refund now on money you contribute, but will have to pay tax later, on money you withdraw from the plan. This difference, along with your income, your investment timeline, and other factors will all contribute to making the right decision for your investment dollars. You may find that you can use both vehicles simultaneously. Read on to learn more.
1. Income and tax bracket
Which is better? The short answer:
- RRSPs if you make over $50,000
- TFSAs if you make under $50,000
Your income determines your tax bracket—the amount of income tax you have to pay—and these factors will strongly influence which investments work best for you.
As a general rule, those making more than $50,000 annually will do well to invest in an RRSP. This is because the money you put in is tax deductible and your deductions go towards reducing what you owe. For those who make less than $50,000 per year, the deduction is less valuable, because after claiming basic tax credits, you aren’t likely to owe much income tax. In these cases, putting your money into a TFSA may make more sense.
2. Time horizon
Which is better? The short answer:
- RRSPs for longer term savings goals, like retirement
- TFSAs for short or medium term savings goals, like an emergency fund or buying a car
Anytime you make an investment, it’s a good idea to identify exactly what you’re saving for. Putting away money for retirement is usually on a longer timeline than, say, your child’s education fund or a home renovation.
Your RRSP money is earmarked for your retirement. The program is designed so that when you withdraw the money you will be earning less, and therefore in a lower tax bracket and so will pay less overall tax in your lifetime. This works well for its intended purpose but does not help you with short- or medium-term goals. That’s where a TFSA might work better, given that you can make withdrawals tax-free, and with no penalties. Money invested in a TFSA could easily be withdrawn to buy a car, for example, with no tax implications.
Compare the Best RRSP Investments*
3. Group plans
Which is better? The short answer:
- Almost always RRSPs if you get a company match (it’s free money, after all)
If you receive a matching contribution from your employer on a group RRSP or a similar tax-deferred account like a defined contribution (DC) pension plan, investing in your RRSP could be even more valuable than usual. The way employer contributions tend to work is that your company will match a percentage of your salary when you invest the same percentage, or a percentage of what you contribute—sometimes dollar for dollar. This free money is an automatic return on your investment that would be pretty much impossible to obtain through investing.
Let’s look a little closer. An employer match of even 2% on a $70,000 income results in an extra $1,400 in your RRSP—and your employer’s portion of the contribution may also count towards your RRSP deduction for tax purposes. This is a double benefit and will likely tilt your preference in favour of a workplace account over other savings options unless the match is low, or the investment options are terrible.
4. Buying your first home or saving for education
Which is better? The short answer:
- Usually RRSPs, due to the availability of the Home Buyers’ Plan and Lifelong Learning Plan
Remember how your RRSP is designed for your retirement? There are a few notable caveats to that, in the form of the Home Buyers’ Plan, and the Lifelong Learning Plan.
The Home Buyers Plan (HBP) allows eligible home-buyers to withdraw up to $35,000 from their RRSP to put towards their purchase. The withdrawal is tax-free and must be repaid within 15 years. This is a great way to access a large lump sum, like for a down payment and, though it must be repaid, the “loan” is interest-free.
Similarly, the Lifelong Learning Plan (LLP) is a program that allows you to use your RRSP savings towards your own (or your spouse’s) full-time education or training, up to $20,000 over two years. The amount must be repaid within 10 years.
5. In retirement
Which is better? The short answer:
- Almost always RRSPs (but depends on your income, as covered in section 1)
Withdrawals from TFSAs are always tax-free, whether you’re working or retired. Withdrawals from RRSPs are always taxable. If you’re in retirement, you are likely in a lower tax bracket than prior to your retirement, which means that RRSP withdrawals will be taxed at a lower rate than when you earned the money you originally contributed. Tip: If you find that you have a tax refund, you can maximize it by reinvesting the balance into a TFSA.
When saving and planning for retirement, it pays to take a considered and long-term approach with your decisions—and to personalize them. Whether on your own or with a professional, retirement planning can help validate your choices and assist you to set targets for the future.
READ MORE ON 2021 TAXES:
- We break down the tax brackets in Canada for 2021 (and provinces, too) based on annual income
- What can you claim on your income taxes: 7 deductions not to miss
- How to do your taxes and beat procrastination
- TFSA contribution room calculator
What does the * mean?
If a link has an asterisk (*) at the end of it, that means it's an affiliate link and can sometimes result in a payment to MoneySense (owned by Ratehub Inc.) which helps our website stay free to our users. It's important to note that our editorial content will never be impacted by these links. We are committed to looking at all available products in the market, and where a product ranks in our article or whether or not it's included in the first place is never driven by compensation. For more details read our MoneySense Monetization policy.
Share this article Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linkedin Share on Reddit Share on Email
Related Articles
Home buyers: How large should your down payment be?
Is it best to maximize your down payment on...
How much should you withdraw from your RRIF?
Sandy wants to deplete a registered retirement income fund...
Can you change your mind about taking CPP early?
Rena started receiving Canada Pension Plan benefits at age...
Making sense of the markets this week: July 5, 2021
Why investors should pay attention to the CAPE ratio;...
Tax planning for Canadians who invest in the U.S.
There are good reasons for Canadians to invest in...
Presented by CPP Investments
TFSA contribution room calculator
Figure out how much you can put into a...
Making sense of the markets this week: February 15, 2021
You can now use bitcoin to buy a Tesla,...
I’m 65 and just 4 years ago i started putting money into an rrsp. i have a little over 15 grand. i also have a tfsa but its much lower at about a grand. I’m tempted to take my rrsp’s and put them in my tfsa.
Can someone tell me if this would be a smart thing to do, after all i believe your not taxed on tfsa’s
Thnx, ray
HI Ray, thanks for asking.
Due
to the large volume of comments we receive, we regret that we are unable to respond directly to each one. We invite you to email your question to [email protected],
where it will be considered for a future response by one of our expert columnists. For personal advice, we suggest consulting with your financial institution or a qualified advisor.
As my husband and I are very close to retirement we were wondering if this 4% rule is based on your cash portfolio (RRSP’s, TFSA and Investments) or is it based on your entire asset portfolio, RRSP’s, Investments, TFSA, and Real Estate holdings (primary and other).
Thanks
Gail
Response from the MoneySense editorial team:
Hello Gail, thank you for asking.
Due to the large volume of comments we receive, we regret that we are unable to respond directly to each one. We invite you to email your question to [email protected],
where it will be considered for a future response by one of our expert columnists. For personal advice, we suggest consulting with your financial institution or a qualified advisor.
Thank you! Very clear and concise explanation. Love this article!
You won’t necessary pay taxes on RRSP withdrawals if you are under your personal credits. ie: A senior couple can have an income of 46k (50k by 2023) before paying any tax
Good discussion, but I have issues with #5. The TFSA is ALWAYS better in retirement. For example, a $5,000 RRSP withdrawal will result in 20% or more in tax, leaving $4,000 to spend. A $5,000 TFSA withdrawal will provide $5,000 to spend, completely tax free!
In any case, you cannot make the assumption that you will be in a lower tax bracket at retirement, as seniors’ tax rates are generally much higher at lower income levels than rates at pre retirement. The income tax rate approaches 50% once retirement income exceeds $79,000, due to the impact of the OAS clawback.
I’m 18 and just started university. I want to get ahead in my savings for my retirement as well as savings for a house for the future. I’m really struggling to figure out which one to start. Should I do both?
Due to the large volume of comments we receive, we regret that we are unable to respond directly to each one. We invite you to email your question to [email protected], where it will be considered for a future response by one of our expert columnists. For personal advice, we suggest consulting with your financial institution or a qualified advisor.
“Tip: If you find that you have a tax refund, you can maximize it by reinvesting the balance into a TFSA.”
If you have space in both RRSP and TFSA why is it preferable to invest the refund I be a TFSA?
There should be a section on which is best when you pay into a pension plan through work and expect to receive a pension upon retirement. I believe this tilts the decision towards TFSA to a much higher salary than $50,000.
This is a decent guide, but things are unfortunately a bit more complicated than this. For many people, the TFSA is the better option, even in some situations where it says otherwise in this guide.
For example, in #2, it may very well be to your advantage to invest for retirement in a TFSA if you have a long time horizon. This is because the compounding interest won’t be taxable on the way out. E.g.: say you’re 30, and you have $2500 to invest. At 7% compounding interest for 35 years, this will grow to almost 28,000, with 25,500 of it being sheer interest! Well, in your TFSA, that 25,500 won’t be taxable when you take it out. But in an RRSP it would be. Even with a very low taxable rate of ~20% on the way out, you’re paying $5000 in taxes! This dwarfs any “savings” you get from investing pre-tax now, even accounting for different tax brackets.
Secondly (and this is criminally underreported), folks who don’t expect to have or make a lot of money in retirement should almost always invest in a TFSA. This is because withdrawals from your TFSA don’t count as income for tax purposes, but RRSP withdrawals do. And because it counts as income, it lowers your eligibility for things like the Guaranteed Income Supplement. You are literally working against your ability to receive GIS support by investing in a RRSP instead of a TFSA if you aren’t a person of means; see research and articles by Richard Shillington.
In other words, if you have a very long investment horizon, or if you don’t expect to have a lot of income upon retirement, the TFSA is likely to be better for you. The RRSP is useful primarily if:
– you’re able to get employer matching through it (obviously)
– you believe you’ll be buying a home soon through HBP
– you’re in a higher tax bracket and expect to be so even in retirement; or
– you don’t have a long time investment horizon
In most other cases, the TFSA is more useful in the long-term as well as short.
RRSP’S – THE BIGGEST SCAM GOING
I have maintained for years now that the RRSP is the biggest scam going. You are seduced by a “tax refund”, which you often spend anyway. You lock up money that is not guaranteed to compound at a rate anywhere near the rate at which it will be taxed down the road.
RRSP’s serve one main purpose, to ensure the government will continue to collect tax after age 71. If the annuitant has no spouse due to death or divorce, upon death the CRA considers all assets in the RRSP deemed to be sold as INCOME and taxed in the year of death. So, you see an elderly person with good intentions of leaving their children a sizeable inheritance is duped. This is because the taxes on say a $200,000 RRSP in Ontario, Canada, will be taxed $72,773. That means that the net amount left is $127,227. The average tax rate is 36.4%. Basically this means many years of earned returns have evaporated instantly in a puff of smoke.
If you have a considerable amount of assets in your RRSP you also risk losing other “free” government benefits such as OAS, GIS, and Drug Benefits due to CRA claw-back provisions. It’s a no-brainer. Choose TFSA and avoid getting burned by the CRA.
Robert Botnick
CANADIAN CENTS I.Q.